Circles of Support and Accountability

March 5, 2021
Posted in Blog
March 5, 2021 Editor

Circles of Support and Accountability

Please click on audio of post. NOTE: only main text read; no links, text markings, images, videos, footnotes, etc. read aloud.

WN: I have had the good fortune of working with CoSA one way or another since its inception in 1994. You may read about the beginnings here.

I served since inception as well on the Board of CoSA Canada for two 3-year terms, taking a mandated break this year. I am currently working with others to develop a two-track–one academic, one non–curriculum that may be widely used by CoSAs, and by academic institutions.

Needless to say, I believe in Restorative Justice and CoSA!

The local program was begun under the BC Restorative Justice Program I directed for 16 years–until retirement–in partnership with Correctional Services Canada Chaplaincy (Pacific Region), headed by good friend Gerry Ayotte; and I was variously volunteer Board member, staff member, and volunteer from 1974 to 2014.

Two pages on this site besides many Blog posts are: Restorative Justice and a book series I am publishing, Justice That Transforms–Book Series–First 3 Volumes Fall 2018.

In retirement, I continue–some with Esther, my wife–volunteering with several RJ programs, some national, others international. All very meaningful.

And I continue volunteering with the local program: CoSA-Vancouver/Fraser Valley (CoSA-VFV). I serve on a committee, and soon will join a third Circle. This too is very meaningful. It feels simply, as in all the above, a privilege.

Please click on the highlighted text to learn much about our local Program, to meet our highly capable and experienced Director, Maureen Donegan, including in the following video:

Then please read the following article connecting CoSA and loneliness, by a colleague with whom, as indicated above, we and others are developing a CoSA curriculum.

LONELINESS AND RESTORATIVE JUSTICE

by Otto Driedger, Professor Emeritus University of Regina

February 2021

I came across an article in Maclean’s, March 2021 which reminded me of the experience we (my wife Florence and I) have with persons coming back into society from incarceration and becoming  core members in Circles of Support and Accountability (CoSA). It also reminded me of the many other ways in which we have been and continue to be involved in restorative justice issues and services.

The article makes reference to the book The Lonely Century: How to Restore Human Connection in a World That’s Pulling Apart by Noreena Hertz. Reference is also made to the book A Biography of Loneliness: The History of an Emotion by British historian Fay Bound Alberti and numerous other references. In addition she discusses many other experiences and references to research that address causes of loneliness, its implications and responses that have emerged.

In terms of causes, it is observed that increased loneliness began with “industrialization, the growth of the consumer economy, the declining influence of religion and the popularity of evolutionary biology, all of which helped propel the rise of individualism.”  Alberti further states “COVID … has exposed every crack in our society from income inequality to our trust in one another, and exacerbated them all.  But it caused none of them. As the researchers of the ‘loneliness epidemic’ demonstrated years ago, we were already there.”

Hertz quotes research on the effects of loneliness. “Nor is there any dispute over how deadly loneliness and social isolation can be. They have been tightly connected with a range of health problems, from heart attacks and strokes increasing by about 30%, to alcohol and drug abuse, to anxiety, depression and a staggering 64% higher chance of clinical dementia. In the now famous summation of a 2015 meta-analysis of studies that totalled 3.4million people tracked over seven years, loneliness is far worse than obesity, worse than 15 cigarettes a day.”  She also identifies the increase in intimate partner and elder abuse and mental health issues.

Three major societal phenomena are identified as a result of loneliness.

  • First, in industrially advanced capitalist societies several unique services have emerged. Examples cited include the development of a for-profit agency that provides cuddles for hire at hourly rates of $40 to $80.00.  In another example, some aged Japanese too poor to purchase robots as companions, commit minor crimes. One 78 year-old prisoner who lives alone described jail as “an oasis” where there are many people to talk to.
  • Second, the rise of commercial co-working spaces has seen the rise of companies providing such space. The importance of eating together at work places has a profound effect on productivity. The importance of doing things or being together as compared to being alone together.
  • The third point is the role of loneliness and alienation in the rise of political populism, especially “the contemporary world’s dominant right-wing variety.” Hertz cites a major study of 600 individuals in 17 European countries and found that “people who were members of civic associations—volunteer groups and neighbourhood associations—were significantly less likely to vote for right-wing populist parties than people who were not.”

The article resonates with the work we do in restorative justice and CoSAs, the latter a program based on restorative justice principles. We find a large percentage of persons who offend and spend time in the criminal justice system experience profound loneliness, alienation and isolation. Upon returning to society from incarceration frequently means positive relationships have not existed or have been severed by incarceration. Frequently, if a person has offended sexually, he (usually it is a “he”) is abandoned by his family, no communities want him in their neighbourhood, and it is very difficult to get a job.  As a result the major relationships are with other offenders which may lead to further offending.

Circles of Support and Accountability (CoSA) began in Canada in 1994, where an artificial friendship Circle of from 3 to 6 people would meet regularly with the “Core Member” (the person returning from incarceration—“returning citizen”), usually once a week for a substantial amount of time. Such meetings usually continued at least a year or more.  The Circle facilitates positive integration (or reintegration) into society by friendship, acceptance, facilitation of establishing positive relationships, finding housing, jobs and coping with everyday living without resorting to antisocial behaviour.

One core member who had a history of offending sexually against young women shared an experience he had. He said he had gone to a Tim Horton’s to get a coffee, and said he was sure the female server was coming on to him. The Circle volunteers asked him to describe what had happened. It was clear rather that she was doing her duty of being friendly and positive in her job, nothing more. Assisting him to recognize what is “normal” is important.

Research indicates that there is an over-80% pattern of less re-offending by those in a Circle compared to nonmembers. The initial research was done by Dr. Robin Wilson and Andrew McWhinnie (2009). Subsequent research supports the findings. For more information on the research and much else about CoSAs, please visit the CoSA Canada web site.

And of course, if in British Columbia, please also visit the local website highlighted above.

Further: Otto and Florence Driedger, octogenarians, are a dynamic team who have worked together tirelessly for decades in service to CoSA–and a host of other helping ministries. They received a delightful letter from Psychologist Fred A. Reekie, PhD CSAT of Moving Forward: Individual & Couple Counselling in Saskatoon. In part, Dr. Reekie wrote1:

Recovery for sex addicts is most effective when there is a three-pronged approach: therapy, 12-Step Recovery Programs, and a Social Support Network. When roadblocks are placed in the way of these men accessing services at this critical moment, they experience that denial as a rejection of themselves as people. They interpret the message, “We cannot provide services until you are sentenced,” as “You are so deeply defective and hopeless as a human being that you are unworthy of our help.” This is toxic shame; it is no longer about what they did; it is about who they are. They give up. When these men make their first contact with me, they often phrase the request for therapy in the language of “Do you work with people like me?” The phrase “people like me” reflects the horrible truth that they see themselves as less than human and they anticipate rejection and abandonment.

The opposite of addiction is connection. CoSA provides a unique and vital role in the restoration of these men to wholeness. The acceptance provided by professionals like myself is often dismissed because we are paid to see them. Involvement in a 12-Step Recovery Group is often dismissed as, “Sure, they accept me because they are like me, but normal people would never want me.” CoSA counters that narrative in the most powerful way. When, at their lowest and most vulnerable moment, a Circle of “normal people” welcomes these men in, that experience disputes the message of toxic shame in a way that a therapist and a 12-Step Group cannot. Your welcoming them into a Circle says, “We see you, we have compassion for you, we believe in you, you have value, and we will walk with you as your spiritual companions through this valley. You are not alone.”

He could not have expressed it more beautifully! Then a challenge:

Please, consider expanding your mandate to include those who have just been charged and not yet sentenced, and even better, those who have not been charged but are sitting alone in their pain with nowhere to turn. Thank you again for your incredible work with some of society’s most hurting and vulnerable people. If I can support your work in any way, it would be my privilege.

Probably “toxic shame” is redundant. All shame is arguably toxic. Makes us believe we are undeserving, without dignity, a mistake. Then along come CoSA volunteers who start with acknowledgement: of the great harm(s) done by the Core Member. No sugar-coating. And we fully hold the CM ever after accountable to create no more victims. We also say, But no one is disposable, and in the words of Columnist Barbara Kay (see below), we intentionally embrace “ministering to the lepers most of us cannot bear to look at.”

The phrase ‘the loneliness epidemic’ went viral long before lockdowns isolated us even further (Eric Gaillard/Reuters)

Also, Maclean’s published, as Otto mentioned, (March 3, 2021): Friend rentals and robots: How businesses are creating solutions for the loneliness epidemic. It of course picks up on some of the same sources as Otto’s article. Here are some excerpts:

Alberti pushes the origin of the loneliness crisis back two centuries, to around 1800, when the word “lonely,” previously far more akin to the neutral “solitary” than it is now, first became a negative emotive word. When the poet William Wordsworth “wandered lonely as a cloud,” he was not expressing pain. The standard word at the time for the state of being alone was “oneliness,” likewise an unemotional statement of fact. Within a few decades, however, loneliness was freighted with the baggage of emptiness and absence it carries today. What happened to it, writes Alberti, was “industrialization, the growth of the consumer economy, the declining influence of religion and the popularity of evolutionary biology,” all of which helped propel the rise of individualism.

Bader, a political progressive as well as a psychologist, agrees with that conclusion, adding that his country’s “mythic sense of the triumph of the individual” is central to a “dog-eat-dog” America submersed in the ethos of the capitalist marketplace. The rise of personal autonomy to society’s highest value has meant “a toxic brew of social isolation and loneliness created by the flip side of the meritocratic myth—the self-doubt and depressive self-criticism caused by the notion that one’s station in life reflects one’s intrinsic value.” Even Rokach, who believes we are seeing more loneliness rather than experiencing more, acknowledges that its expression is culturally determined, and that the lonely in more individualistic countries tend to see themselves as personal failures or, in Trump­ian terms, “losers.” And they tend not to want to admit it: “In 40 years of clinical experience,” says Rokach, “only one patient has ever opened treatment by saying his problem was loneliness.”

Or simply for uncommon human connection. Other aged Japanese, presumably too poor to buy a robot, had taken to petty crimes in pursuit of jailhouse companionship. In Japan, crimes committed by people 65 and older have quadrupled this century. Scholar Koichi Hamai has recorded how half of them were living alone before going to jail, a place one 78-year-old prisoner described as “an oasis” where there are many people to talk to. Carl, the subject of Hertz’s most arresting interview, turned to cuddles for hire. A good-looking, middle-aged, divorced software engineer in Los Angeles, Carl was lonely and desperate, not for sex, but for touch—a stroke along his arm, a shoulder rub. He heard about Jean, who for US$80 an hour, dispensed strokes and hugs in her studio apartment, and he found the experience—which soon included intimate conversations about his deepest thoughts and concerns—intensely therapeutic. Eventually, once a week with Jean was not enough, and Carl found other professional cuddlers. As his costs rose to US$2,000 a month, Carl abandoned his home and started to live in his car. “I was astounded when he told me that,” recalls an emotional Hertz. “What a stain on society that this is where we’ve got to, with people so desperate for affection, having to live in their cars. But his story is also kind of a mark of how omnipotent the market is in providing a ‘solution’ to any problem.”

Cuddle buyers and voluntary jailbirds are outliers, of course, and most of the loneliness economy is almost too mundane for most of us to notice. Back when office towers were still packed with workers, one in five in the U.S. reported not having a single friend at work. That’s one in five regular staff, not gig workers on temporary hire, whose office friendship rates would be closer to zero. That’s because, Hertz argues, the modern workplace has long lacked what it takes to build community. The open-plan office, born out of cost-cutting, “was sold to employees as a place where they were more likely to co-operate and collaborate, but in practice, became a kind of dystopian panopticon where people put on their noise-cancelling headphones and communicate by text and email with their colleagues.” Other workplace rituals have also been lost in recent years, “like eating together and having breaks at the same time, rather than eating alone at your desk.”

The meal issue may sound small, Hertz agrees, but it can make a major difference. Behavioural scientists at Cornell University spent nearly a year and a half observing 13 fire stations in a major American city, left unnamed to protect the firefighters’ privacy. The researchers found that the companies who planned their meals together, cooked together and ate together performed twice as well on the job as those who did not, because their collaboration and co-operation were better and more seamless in what is often a life-or-death situation. The firefighters themselves believe eating together is the social glue that creates friendship, mutual trust and teamwork—the daily meal was so important members would sometimes eat twice, once at home and again at the station, because skipping the common meal was a sign of disrespect and estrangement.

Right-wing populists also provide clear-cut, in-group/out-group divisions—who is worthy of inclusion and who is not. There is immense appeal for the lonely in that, Hertz and Bader agree, because they are relieved to be allowed into any group and because their loneliness has already had their brains’ “threat assessment” on high alert. A solitary mouse, isolated for four weeks or longer by curious scientists, will turn brutally and immediately on a newcomer introduced to his cage. Lonely mice and lonely men both turn on one another.

What to do about our frayed communities and lonely selves, nasal spray notwithstanding, has no easy answers. Hertz and other researchers know there are powerful economic currents dragging us where we are, and many good reasons—from abusive families to censorious neighbours—why so many people choose to live alone, whatever the long-term effects may be. Hertz is remarkably even-handed in her discussion of why we live the way we do and the changes—such as taxing internet giants like Amazon to pay for government support for local firms—needed to build the communities we want. Lasting solutions, however, will require awareness and deliberate action from governments, businesses and citizens. And cuddle-yearning Carl, disturbing as his story is, may be pointing us in the right direction. Massage therapy, Alberti says, is one of the few physical treatments proven to alleviate loneliness. Touch, the first and most powerful of human senses, so absent during the pandemic, will be part of the road home.

Finally, a brief (long if you read all the footnotes!) theological reflection about CoSA, in light of all the above.

God in our Christian understanding is a Trinity of loving, deferential interpersonal relationships. In I John, the writer baldly states: God is love. Here is the passage (4:16 & 17):

16And we have come to know and believe the love that God has for us. God is love; whoever abides in love abides in God, and God in him. 17In this way, love has been perfected among us, so that we may have confidence on the day of judgment; for in this world we are just like Him.

God therefore abides in love in a never-ending yet dynamic dance of mutual-love-in-liberty-and-community.  (Some theologians even suggest we thereby collectively (ideally) as Church become by extension–and paradoxically–the fourth memeber of the Trinity.) And we all have been invited to join that dance! Yet our human condition means, in verse 17, that we must insert ideally before “perfected,” and exchange ought to be for “are” in the last phrase. But the oughtness is in reality glorious invitation: a summons to enter into The Wildest Dance of Freedom available on the planet! In fact, in light of an early Christian hymn quoted in verses 6 to 8 of Philippians 2:1 – 11,2 Christian faith offers the grand privilege of sidestepping one’s grasping Ego in favour of a True Self.3

Another corollary from this passage is: we are found most to be made in God’s image when we practise community–an intentional thriving community of mutual love. This insight is found too in the African concept of ubuntu: A person is a person through others.

A further commentary on this understanding is beautifully expressed in an interview with Orthodox priest and scholar, Father Thomas Hopko, in Living in Communion: AN INTERVIEW WITH FATHER THOMAS HOPKO. A brief excerpt (but please click on and read the whole interview):

Thomas Hopko: Yes. I would prefer the word communion to relationship, but yes. The Orthodox approach is that we are made in the image and likeness of God, and that God is a Trinity of persons in absolute identity of being and of life in perfect communion. Therefore, communion is the given. Anything that breaks that communion destroys the very roots of our existence. That’s why forgiveness is essential if there is going to be human life in the image of God. We are all sinners, living with other sinners, and so seventy—times—seven’’ times a day we must reestablish the communion—and want to do so. The desire is the main thing, and the feeling that it is of value.

Just over 10 years into the work of CoSA, National Post columnist Barbara Kay reflected on CoSA thus4:

How do volunteers come to “care” about such human wreckage? It helps to be a Christian, as 75% of the volunteers are. One says of her role that it “is not of my own choosing or making, but from God … This is God saying, ‘You have to do something about this.'” Remarkably, the volunteers make no attempt to convert their charges. Their involvement is purely dutiful, pragmatic and unselfish.

With expansion, recruitment of volunteers becomes harder. I suspect Christians will continue to be the majority among them. The Christian faith, uniquely among the world’s religions, has inspired an awesome tradition of ministering to the lepers most of us cannot bear to look at.

One must acknowledge that in the two plus millennia since Christ, sadly, that is not all it inspired!5

CoSA has significantly expanded to many places worldwide, and has also undergone numerous academic evaluations that demonstrate it is by far the most effective intervention worldwide for sex offenders returning to society. For in the end, The Beloved Community6 is the only successful and sustained “tool” in interventions for good that we humans have.7

So a shout-out to CoSA and to all involved! In the end, because it reflects ultimately God’s very Trinitarian essence, it is the only kind of worthwhile show on the planet!

Amen.

Footnotes
  1. The full letter may be read–with his permission–here.[]
  2. 1Therefore if you have any encouragement in Christ, if any comfort from His love, if any fellowship with the Spirit, if any affection and compassion, 2then make my joy complete by being like-minded, having the same love, being united in spirit and purpose.

    3Do nothing out of selfish ambition or empty pride, but in humility consider others more important than yourselves. 4Each of you should look not only to your own interests, but also to the interests of others.

    5Let this mind be in you which was also in Christ Jesus:

    6Who, existing in the form of God,

    did not consider equality with God

    something to be grasped,a

    7but emptied Himself,

    taking the form of a servant,

    being made in human likeness.

    8And being found in appearance as a man,

    He humbled Himself

    and became obedient to death—

    even death on a cross.

    []

  3. Please click on True Self to view a compelling reflection by Sister Ilia Delio on Thoman Merton‘s–drawing on the Church Mothers and Fathers–understanding of what our True Self is.[]
  4. Other mentions about CoSA in her writings are here.[]
  5. See however (adduced in my Easter Song, Keith Green, and Reflections on the ResurrectionSir Larry Siedentop’s Inventing the Individual: The Origins of Western Liberalism, that does a sweep of 1800 years of Western history, demonstrating that

    The roots of liberalism—belief in individual freedom, in the fundamental moral equality of individuals, in a legal system based on equality, and in a representative form of government befitting a society of free people—all these were pioneered by Christian thinkers of the Middle Ages who drew on the moral revolution carried out by the early Church. These philosophers and canon lawyers, not the Renaissance humanists, laid the foundation for liberal democracy in the West.–from description of book highlighted above; emphasis added).

    See too my (long!) book review of Terry Eagleton‘s brilliant Reason, Faith and Revolution: Reflections on the God Debate, for further consideration.[]

  6. See Charles Marsh’s The Beloved Community: How Faith Shapes Social Justice from the Civil Rights Movement to Today.

    From Publishers Weekly

    Starred Review. In this ambitious, wide-ranging book, Marsh, a religion professor at the University of Virginia, argues that the Civil Rights movement was, at its core, a Christian attempt to forge a “beloved community” of believers who identify with the poor and dispossessed and seek justice on their behalf. As his alternative telling unfolds, he introduces readers to a Martin Luther King Jr. they may not recognize (one who looked forward to a life of privilege and comfort until he was forced into leadership of the Montgomery Bus Boycott), as well as lesser-known figures such as Koinonia farm founder Clarence Jordan and Voices of Calvary founder John Perkins. Both of these men, like many others featured in the book, came to activism by way of Christian faith and belie the popular notion of “the civil rights movement as a secular movement that used religion to its advantage.” Marsh laces his narrative with powerful critiques of secularism—among both activists and academics—and of white evangelical Christians for shallow, ineffectual concern for the poor and for people of color. He ends on a positive note, however, citing example after example of contemporary Christians eschewing lives of middle-class comfort in favor of attempts to build the beloved community in the most troubled corners of America.
    Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. –This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.

    From Booklist

    Marsh brings fresh perspective to the civil rights movement and the role of religion in social reform. Lamenting efforts by historians to secularize the civil rights movement, Marsh asserts that Christian principles of healing, reconciliation, and redemption were at the heart of the movement. Martin Luther King Jr and others sought not just social justice and national redemption but the “creation of the beloved community” to include citizens of all races living in peace and overcoming a long history of hatred and oppression. Marsh explores the theology behind the more radical approach of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee and the intentional interracial communities that continued efforts at reconciling religion and social reform. Recounting the struggles for racial justice and the spiritual tumult engendered in that search, Marsh offers personal portraits of courage rooted in faith as well as the ongoing debates about personal relationships with Christ and liberation theology and continued tensions between fundamentalists and social progressives. This fascinating, compelling book will appeal to readers with broad interests in religion and social justice. Vanessa Bush
    Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved –This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.[]
  7. It is also so desperately needed instead of  our brutal scapegoating dependency on prisons, as these recent posts (and so much else on this website), Houses of hate: How Canada’s prison system is broken; The Kenarchy Journal (see my Restorative Justice: Peacemaking Not Warmaking; Transformative Justice: Penal Abolitionism Not Prison Reform in Volume Two), indicate.[]

Editor

Wayne Northey was Director of Man-to-Man/Woman-to-Woman – Restorative Christian Ministries (M2/W2) in British Columbia, Canada from 1998 to 2014, when he retired. He has been active in the criminal justice arena and a keen promoter of Restorative Justice since 1974. He has published widely on peacemaking and justice themes. You will find more about that on this website: a work in progress.

Always appreciate constructive feedback! Thanks.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Care to follow posts?

Get the latest posts delivered to your mailbox (unsubscribe any time):

%d bloggers like this: